Toby is saved from drowning by the ghost children who haunt the Hotel Dante, and they continue to follow him. Van and Toby realize that the children are telling them that someone tried to kill Toby -- the same someone that killed them in 1954!

Van’s growing powers attract Grace’s attention. Grace comes looking for her at the Hotel Dante, which she still owns as an absentee landlord. Discovering Van’s paintings and learning that Van possesses one of the two Tresum books – the Book of the Moon – Grace realizes that the newcomer is a possible threat to her. When the older witch challenges her, Van is able to defend herself, but her girlfriend Michelle witnesses the magical battle and storms out. Michelle hates all things supernatural.

Kevin gets a new job working construction at the hotel for local fixer Kai. Toby starts work at H2Eau, newcomer Marco Laveau’s classy new beach bar. Ambrosius meets Adam and they become friendly. Ambrosius gets a new look and a new moniker, as he starts going by the name "Bro." Bro and Kevin get a fresh start, meeting as 'strangers' in H2Eau.

Toby, determined to find out who tried to kill him, follows Cory and finds Ambrosius. The episode ends in a cliffhanger at Ambrosius' new pad, with Cory's and Toby's lives hanging in the balance.